Menu:

 
Vicki sent in an image of her barstools asking for a 2nd Opinion.  These stools are used everyday by her two young daughters, and she says that it shows.  They seem to be currently covered in a rather nubby and decidedly light fabric, nubby doesn't equal easy to clean!  
So my opinion is to embrace the functionality of these chairs, they have to be work horses.  I think Vicki has a few options.  My favorite option for her would be to cover the chairs in oilcloth or a laminated cotton.  Since she would only be covering the seat bottoms I'm certain she could get 2 chair covers out of a yard, possibly three.  That is a steal of a deal.  Clean, highly functional, and customized chairs for under $30, fantastic!  I asked Vicki what her favorite colors were, and she commented that she really likes earthy tones and that she has been picking out oranges a lot lately. My opinion is that the fabric should be bright with some contrast to the dark wood.  It's a very straight lined chair, we need to mix it up with some pattern .  Here are my picks, click on the image to be taken to the retailer:     
Picture
And at $6.99 a yard it's a total steal!
Picture
Kind of Kelly Wearstler inspired right?
Picture
This is actually laminated cotton, a little easier to manipulate, a bit more expensive too.
Picture
This colorway is called spice, perfect for dining chairs!
I have to admit when I saw Vicki's chairs my mind went back to a blog post I read years ago.  Here's the image that was permanently fixed in my brain:
Darling right?  The tutorial for the slip covers can be found here at Dana Made It.  Now that I've swayed the vote :)  let's see what you readers think!